
HOT TOPIC | NOVEMBER 2026 – Grievances are changing – is your organisation ready?

1. Introduction
In this month’s Hot Topic we examine the evolving nature of workplace grievances, including the rise of tactical complaints, common procedural pitfalls and the wider impact on organisations. We’ll share practical guidance to help you manage grievances fairly, reduce legal risk and ensure your policies, procedures and managers are equipped to deal with today’s workplace challenges.
2. How grievances are evolving
Workplace grievances are becoming more common, increasingly complex, strategic, and time-consuming, creating substantial legal, financial, and operational risks for employers. Historically, formal grievances were rare administrative events; a complaint was logged, a meeting was held, an outcome letter was issued, and the matter was concluded.
Today, dispute management has fundamentally changed. Organisations are increasingly dealing with lengthy, legally framed complaints driven by advancements in Artificial Intelligence (AI) and impending legislative shifts.
3. How AI and legislative reform is driving grievances
Artificial Intelligence (AI)
Artificial Intelligence has dramatically altered how employees frame workplace complaints. Generative AI platforms enable workers to draft polished, structured submissions complete with quotes from employment legislation, case law, and formal legal arguments.
However, AI tools are prone to errors. Employees using public AI models may submit complaints containing fabricated legal citations or real precedents misapplied to their specific scenario. Furthermore, a serious concern for businesses, is when employees use public AI platforms to share confidential information, exposing the business to risk and data protection breaches.
If you want to read more about how AI is shaping employee relations, read our July Hot Topic (the AI powered employee – should employers be worried?), for which there is also a webinar on demand to accompany.
The Changing Legal Landscape
Legislative updates under the Employment Rights Act 2025 expand the pool of eligible claimants and significantly increase potential Employment Tribunal (ET) compensation awards. Because employees are required to fully exhaust their organisation’s internal grievance procedure before lodging claims such as discrimination or harassment, this mandatory prerequisite, combined with a broader base of eligible employees, is expected to trigger a substantial surge in formal internal grievances.
4. Tactical complaints
While tactical grievances are not new, AI tools and expanding legal rights are accelerating their use. A tactical grievance is a complaint submitted not primarily to resolve an underlying workplace issue, but to delay, derail, or gain leverage during ongoing processes such as performance management, disciplinary proceedings, probation reviews, or settlement negotiations.
Legal Caution: ‘Tactical grievance’ is a descriptive term, not a legal defence. Nothing in employment law permits an employer to set aside a complaint simply because its timing is inconvenient or strategic.
A complaint raised during a performance review may be entirely genuine and could explain the performance issues. Dismissing a grievance as tactical without investigation creates evidence of procedural unfairness. Employers must maintain two parallel principles: treat every complaint on its merits while keeping legitimate management processes moving that are fair and reasonable.
5. Common pitfalls
Failing to follow the Acas Code of Practice on Disciplinary and Grievance Procedures allows an Employment Tribunal to adjust final compensation awards by up to 25% for unreasonable non-compliance. Organisations should avoid these 11 widespread pitfalls:
- Dismissing AI-generated submissions: Rejecting a grievance on technical or stylistic grounds ignores core legal risks; employers must investigate the underlying facts regardless of how the document was drafted.
- Failing to recognise grievances: A grievance does not require formal legal terminology or official HR forms. Concerns raised in one to ones, emails, exit interviews, or surveys can trigger statutory obligations.
- Assuming bad faith: Viewing a complaint as exaggerated, malicious, or ill-timed introduces defensive bias. Every grievance must be treated as genuine until disproved by objective fact-finding.
- Conflating separate processes: Merging a grievance directly into an active disciplinary or performance review can compromise fairness. While processes may run concurrently or pause based on context, they must be managed with clear distinction.
- Retaliation (or the appearance of it): Altering duties, isolating staff, or accelerating performance actions post-complaint creates strong inferences of unlawful victimisation.
- Overlooking hidden legal dimensions: Treating complex grievances merely as interpersonal friction risks missing underlying statutory protections, such as whistleblowing disclosures or harassment claims.
- Appointing conflicted or untrained decision makers: Assigning managers who are named in the complaint or lack dispute resolution training compromises procedural integrity and invites tribunal penalties.
- Delay and silence: Extended silence erodes the implied duty of trust and confidence, often underpinning constructive dismissal claims.
- Weak documentation: Poor or delayed record-keeping makes proving a fair process difficult. Gaps in documenting informal resolution attempts will face scrutiny under updated Acas guidance expected in 2027.
- Mishandling confidential & personal data: Inputting grievance details into public AI tools or sharing statements carelessly creates severe UK GDPR exposure alongside employment risks and breaches employer confidentiality.
- Over-relying on NDAs & financial settlements: Using non-disclosure agreements (NDAs) and financial payouts as a default fix masks systemic issues. NDAs cannot suppress protected disclosures or discrimination claims.
6. Understanding victimisation and retaliation
Under the Equality Act 2010, victimisation occurs when an employee is subjected to a detriment (treated badly) because they performed a protected act.
Statutory protected acts include:
- Making a discrimination complaint.
- Bringing an Employment Tribunal claim under the Equality Act.
- Giving evidence or support in connection with another employee’s proceedings.
- Doing anything else in connection with equality legislation, such as raising an internal grievance.
7. Operational and financial impact on organisations
Grievance management is no longer just an HR function; it carries direct operational and financial consequences:
- Escalating financial stakes: The extension of tribunal claim timeframes, upcoming early protections against unfair dismissal (January 2027), and the planned removal of the statutory compensation cap (January 2027) significantly heighten financial exposure.
- Threat to SME stability: Combined with potential 25% Acas compensation uplifts, procedural mistakes in a single mismanaged dispute can threaten the financial viability of small and medium-sized enterprises.
- Management time and effort & cultural impact: Protracted grievances consume extensive management time and effort. Furthermore, how leadership responds signals whether speaking up is safe; unaddressed issues often re-emerge later as formal claims, sudden resignations, or public disclosures.
8. Managing grievances fairly
The underlying principles for managing grievances are not new, but the cost of getting them wrong has escalated. Check out our key points for managing grievances safely:
- Apply the same approach to perceived ‘tactical’ complaints: Even if you may think a complaint is tactical, you must treat it as genuine until facts disprove it. There can be legitimacy even if there is an element of ‘tactical’ play going on.
- Recognise and acknowledge promptly: Train managers to spot grievances regardless of format and acknowledge receipt in writing within a few working days with clear timelines.
- Clarify core complaints: If a submission is lengthy or unstructured, ask the employee to specify key issues, supporting evidence, and desired outcomes to prevent points from being missed.
- Explore & document informal resolution: Utilise facilitated conversations or workplace mediation where appropriate. Explicitly record why informal steps were taken or why they were deemed unsuitable.
- Appoint independent decision makers: Ensure investigators and decision makers are impartial, independent of one another, and not named in the complaint. Use external HR support if internal objectivity is compromised.
- Manage parallel processes carefully: Document whether to pause, combine, or run parallel disciplinary/performance procedures based on their connection to the grievance.
- Conduct proportionate investigations: Maintain focused, contemporaneous written records, interviewing relevant witnesses and gathering facts strictly aligned with the issues.
- Prevent retaliation: Brief managers on legal detriment and what ‘victimisation’ means.
- Handle whistleblowing appropriately: Recognise disclosures of wrongdoing even if the worker does not use formal whistleblowing terminology.
- Extend document retention & governance: Retain grievance records longer to account for extended tribunal claim timeframes ensuring strict compliance to the UK GDPR.
9. Policy audits and executive review checklists
Is your business seeing an increase in grievances, particularly ones you suspect are AI generated? Ask yourself these questions to help you determine whether any action needs to be taken to ensure your policies and procedures are robust enough to respond to this new challenge.
Grievance policy checklist
- Does the policy align with the Acas Code and accommodate upcoming legal revisions?
- Does it offer routes for informal resolution and mediation without forcing them?
- Does it outline procedures for clarifying long, complex, or AI-assisted grievances?
- Does it clearly define how to handle parallel disciplinary or capability processes?
- Are template letters (acknowledgment, invitation, outcome) fully up to date?
Executive board questions
- Can every line manager correctly identify and escalate a grievance, whistleblowing concern, or harassment complaint?
- Are independent investigators assigned for decision-making roles, including fallback options for small teams?
- Has an audit been conducted on how HR and managers handle data privacy and AI tools during grievance procedures?
10. Further Information
Register for our webinar: Grievances are changing, is your organisation ready?
Our webinar is taking place Thursday 12 November, 10am-11am, during which, we will explore in more detail, the changes discussed above, what they mean in practice, and what employers should do to remain compliant and reduce risk.
You can register here.
Your Knowledge Base
As a Knowledge Base member, you have access to our template documents, checklists, guides and policies. In addition, access to a wide range or employment articles.
11. Future developments
To support our clients, we are undertaken a full review of our employment documents to ensure they can operate robustly alongside the use of AI. We shall also be publishing an updated AI in the workplace policy. Our current version is available here, and you can access our template impact assessment

